Now Reading
The #Foodheaux Goes To: The Poni Room American Izakaya Bar in NYC

The #Foodheaux Goes To: The Poni Room American Izakaya Bar in NYC

When I moved to NYC years ago I knew nothing about nothing. Friends guided me to places that they thought I would like and Saxon + Parole was one of them. It makes sense now since AvroKO Hospitality is responsible for some of my favorite go-to’s to this day. If you aren’t familiar,  Saxon + Parole is an American meat and whiskey-centric eatery with an equestrian-theme situated on the corner of Bowery and Bleecker in NoHo near The Bowery Hotel. They do an awesome Derby Party every year.

Nowadays I do know a lot about a lot and as a seasoned NYC Foodheaux, I was surprised when I heard the location of The Poni Room because surely if it was on that corner I would’ve seen it. Every single fitness studio I frequent is within a three-block radius.

Then I learned this little hideaway isn’t visible from the street. It’s tucked underneath Saxon + Parole which made me extra excited to uncover this gem.

The Vibe

This spot is the perfect date night or friend catch up location since it’s so intimate. Sharing small plates (everything here is meant to be eaten family-style) and copious amounts of wine seem to play well with both. Once you check off the items you want on the menu head back to the very Instagrammable Rose Tub and pour yourself a pitcher in still, sparkling, or slushie form.

What To Order

SEARED RARE TUNA | green tea noodles, snow pea salad

Come for the Rose tub and stay for the green tea noodles. They are served cold and have a taste that isn’t quite what the name might lead you to believe but I promise they are the most delicious thing on the menu.

BBQ Oysters | shrimp-chili paste, scallion-cucumber salad

What’s better than raw oysters with happy hour drinks? The BBQed variety with a spicy sauce and bits of fresh cucumber.

SALMON TARTARE TROUT ROE | trout roe, avocado, cucumber, rice chip, cherry wood smoke

If there’s roe on it, I order it.  Oh, and avocado, too. It’s a salty, creamy-crunchy mouthfeel that consistency aficionados must have stat.

Price Point

Very affordable (for NYC) depending on what you order. Small plates and wine won’t break the bank (~$45p/p) but the large plates get slightly pricier – not so bad between 2-3 people though.


Green tea noods are INSANITY!

If it's a party night get a pitcher of Rose slushie and don't look back.

You found your next date night/GNO spot.


The lighting in the Rose room is harsh.

Hard to find ...but that's not totally a bad thing.

Can get loud once all of the tables are filled.

View Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

© 2020 To Be Honest Tho. All Rights Reserved.

Scroll To Top